YOUR BRAIN IS LYING TO YOU—AND YOU KEEP BELIEVING IT

Published on 14 November 2026 at 20:22

Why the stories we tell ourselves can be more frightening than reality

Have you ever had an argument with someone who wasn't even in the room?

You imagined what they were going to say. You planned your response. You anticipated their reaction. You got frustrated with what you imagined they were thinking.  And by the time you actually saw them, you were already upset!

Congratulations. You've just had an argument that never happened.

The other person didn't even know they were participating.  It's funny when you think about it. But it's also a little disturbing.

How often do we allow something that hasn't happened to influence how we feel, think, and behave?

More often than most of us would like to admit.

Our minds are remarkably good at creating stories. Unfortunately, they're not always very good at distinguishing between what we know and what we imagine.  Sometimes the greatest source of our anxiety isn't what's happening around us.

It's the story we're telling ourselves about what's happening.

YOUR BRAIN IS TRYING TO PROTECT YOU

Your brain isn't actually trying to deceive you.  It’s trying to protect you.

One of its important jobs is anticipating potential danger. It draws upon previous experiences, memories, emotions, and available information to predict what might happen next.

That's incredibly useful.

But consider this example.  You send someone a text message.

They don't respond. That's all you actually know.

But your brain doesn't particularly enjoy uncertainty, so it starts filling in the blanks.

"Did I say something wrong?"

"Are they upset with me?"

"Maybe they don't want to talk to me."

"Something must be wrong."

Before long, you're feeling rejected, frustrated, or anxious. But stop and think about what actually happened. Someone didn't answer a text message. Everything else was a story you created to explain it.

Maybe they're busy. Maybe they're driving. Maybe they forgot to respond. Maybe their phone battery died.

The problem isn't that your interpretation is necessarily wrong. The problem is that you've begun treating an interpretation as though it's an established fact.

And that can get us into trouble.

WHEN OUR MINDS TURN POSSIBILITIES INTO CERTAINTIES

Psychologists have a name for one particularly troublesome thinking pattern. It's called catastrophizing.

Catastrophizing happens when we anticipate an extremely negative outcome, often treating the worst-case scenario as though it's the most likely one.

Your boss says, "I'd like to talk with you tomorrow.”  Immediately, your mind begins working.  ”What did I do wrong?”  And suddenly you're mentally calculating how long you can survive without a paycheck.

All because someone wanted to schedule a conversation.

But maybe your boss wants to discuss a new opportunity.  You don't know.  Yet your emotions are already responding to the worst possible explanation.

Here's another example.

You experience an unfamiliar physical symptom.  You search for it online.

Twenty minutes later, you've mentally diagnosed yourself with three rare diseases and are wondering who will take care of the dog when you're gone.

 

Sound familiar?

 

The problem is that our minds can move from something might happen to something probably will happen without sufficient evidence.

 

And when we repeatedly think about frightening possibilities, those possibilities can begin feeling increasingly real.

But something feeling real doesn't make it true.

Our emotions provide information about how we're responding to a situation. They don't necessarily provide accurate information about the situation itself.

Fear can tell you that something matters to you. It cannot, by itself, tell you what's actually going to happen.

WE DON'T JUST REACT TO LIFE. WE REACT TO OUR INTERPRETATION OF LIFE.

Two people can experience the same event and respond in completely different ways.

Both receive criticism at work.  One thinks, "That's uncomfortable, but maybe there's something I can learn.”  The other thinks, "I'm terrible at my job. Everybody knows it. I'm never going to succeed."

Same event.

Very different interpretations.

Our interpretations can influence our emotional responses, and those responses can influence our decisions.

But here's the good news.

We can learn to examine our thoughts rather than automatically believe everything we think.

That doesn't mean ignoring genuine problems or pretending everything is wonderful.  It means developing the ability to distinguish between reality and assumption.

And that is where wisdom begins.

WHAT DOES GOD SAY ABOUT THE WAY WE THINK?

In Philippians 4:8, Paul writes:

"And now, dear brothers and sisters, one final thing. Fix your thoughts on what is true, and honorable, and right, and pure, and lovely, and admirable. Think about things.”

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.